data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6d6/0b6d6a4980aa502adfbd5161208eeda31bd0537c" alt="Total drama pahkitew island"
While Max puts the wire on his stick, Scarlett throws an electric eel at it, helping him zap Ella and win. After team Kinosewak's first X is complete, Scarlett tells Max to go next, as she has a plan. Scarlett tells him that all of them are good, and he will have a hard time deciding, to which he calls her silly, and replies that an evil name chooses you, not the other way around. When both teams head to the beach for the challenge in "A Blast from the Past", Scarlett walks near Max, while he pens a list of evil nicknames for himself. She receives the final marshmallow of the night, and Chris comments about there being no reason for her to be eliminated. Later in the challenge, Scarlett is randomly selected for the "scare" part of the challenge, and easily applies makeup to a bear, earning her team the point. Scarlett is confused by these actions, and asks about his current well-being, due to his vacant staring at her. In "I Love You, I Love You Knots", Scarlett stops Rodney while walking with him, due to raccoon manure being on the ground, consequently causing him to fall in love with her. Despite her team losing, Scarlett receives a marshmallow and is declared safe. They are then both seen walking through the forest, with Max saying that Scarlett will be fine if she sticks with him, but both are quickly taken out by Dave. Max then tells her to "take notes of his genius", to which Scarlett rolls her eyes. Max and Scarlett team up for the rest of the challenge, taking out Sky. Scarlett, however, thinks it would be better to use sharp objects in order to pop the other teams' balloons onto them, which Max steals as his own idea. When she asks what he is doing, he tells her that he wants to make a device to shoot balloons from a safe distance. During the challenge Scarlett walks over to Max to see what he's doing but accidentally startles him, causing him to jump into a bush. Scarlett, just like Rodney, Topher and Max, glares at Sammy.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4bd03/4bd038cd4261d817dcb006f9adb9424579b66fe7" alt="total drama pahkitew island total drama pahkitew island"
Amy acts as if she's offended, and hugs Scarlett, who comforts her in another attempt to hide her true nature. In "Twinning Isn't Everything", Scarlett is seen enjoying breakfast with her team, until Samey starts arguing with her sister. When she hears the news that she is once again safe due to team Kinosewak winning the challenge, she tries to cheer up Max by telling him that they won. When she does, the helmet buzzes to life, giving the greased pig evil intentions when she sets it on it's head. She is then asked by Max to hold the helmet when she notices that he forgot to plug it in. Scarlett then uses this to surpass Ella, while completing her own obstacle. She then helps the pig (as well as Amy and Samey) to find its way out of the labyrinth, using pecans. Scarlett sarcastically replies that she has goosebumps. Afterwards, Max asks her about what she thinks about his "Helmet of Evil" and tries to demonstrate how it works on a bunny, though, it does not make the bunny evil. She is told by Jasmine to compete in the fourth part of the obstacle course. When the challenge is explained by Chris, Scarlett points out that there are six obstacles and that they have seven teammates, which leads to Chris saying that two on the team will need to partner up. In "I Love You, Grease Pig!", Scarlett is seen walking with her fellow teammates towards the challenge meeting area, eating berries brought back by Samey and Jasmine. She is safe from elimination, due to team Kinosewak winning the challenge after successfully building a stable shelter. Scarlett is then seen helping her team build their treehouse. She is later seen teaming up with Max to run for supplies, carrying him in a cart behind her along with some wood.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/aa0c8/aa0c8c0975a5599a0b5210e70af0cf7879830083" alt="total drama pahkitew island total drama pahkitew island"
When teams have to find materials for their shelters during the first part of the challenge, Scarlett suggests that they take a wheelbarrow, to which her team agrees. When the zeppelin's engine is destroyed by Chris McLean, Scarlett is one of the seven contestants with actual parachutes, therefore becoming a member of Pimapotew Kinosewak along with Amy, Samey, Max, Topher, Rodney and Jasmine. When she first appears in "So, Uh This is My Team?", she displays her high intelligence by explaining to Sugar that Topher would hit the ground at a much faster rate than she assumed.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0b6d6/0b6d6a4980aa502adfbd5161208eeda31bd0537c" alt="Total drama pahkitew island"